A Broker Playbook to Stop Double Brokering & Cargo Theft

The problem brokers actually face (and why “folders” fail)

Paperwork is compliance; proof is protection. Theft and fraud keep climbing, and the shape of the problem has shifted from missing trailers to identity games at handoff. CargoNet’s latest reads like a weather report in a storm: record 3,625 thefts in 2024 (+27% YoY) and 884 thefts in Q2 2025 (+13% YoY). That rise is powered by impersonation, spoofed domains, and fictitious pickups—tricks that slide between your intake and your dispatch. CargoNet+2CargoNet+2

FMCSA has been blunt: guard against broker/carrier fraud and identity theft. It isn’t a paperwork issue; it’s a moment-of-tender, moment-of-dispatch issue. FMCSA

What works now: carrier verification for brokers (not just onboarding)

Onboarding files the W-9, authority, and COI.
Verification proves reality—twice:

• Entity truth (FMCSA live): names/phones/addresses align; authority active. FMCSA
  
  
• Insurance from the source: COI direct from the agent, not a forwarded image. Truckstop+1
  
  
• Money match: pay-to bank account name = legal entity.
  
  
• Human in the loop: driver ID + liveness at release.
  
  
• Metal bound: plates/VINs on file; unexpected swaps trigger a re-check.
  
  
• App-based dispatch + single doc trail: rate con → stops → BOL/POD in one thread (not six inboxes).
  
  

This is the clean line: verify, then dispatch. You’re not adding friction for good carriers—you’re adding cost to impostors.

Broker workflow (fast, repeatable, measurable)

1. Intake reality check: FMCSA live, COI from agent, bank-to-entity match.
   
   
2. Bind people & assets: ID + liveness for the actual driver; plates/VINs tied.
   
   
3. Dispatch inside the app: identity re-check at handoff; docs and milestones in one chain.
   
   
4. Watch the three moments: at pickup, loaded, out-for-delivery; if detention starts, say it early in-channel.
   
   

Signals to pause: look-alike domains, sudden free webmail on “dispatch,” caller-ID drift, pickup math that lies, last-minute tractor/trailer swaps. These aren’t nitpicks—they’re tells.

What to make non-negotiable (so the process sticks)

• COI provenance: from the agent.
  
  
• Re-verification at release: driver ID/liveness + asset check before the first mile.
  
  
• App handoff + single thread: rate con, comms, and BOL/POD together.
  
  
• Swap rule: any domain/phone/asset/time drift ⇒ re-check or replace.
  
  

Measure it: verification cycle ≤ 7 minutes on new-to-you carriers; 0 unauthorized driver swaps; BOL/POD same day. Quiet boards, faster pay, fewer claims—those are the right scoreboard lights.

Why this approach maps to the 2025 landscape

Identity-driven, “strategic” theft is where the heat is; the data keeps pointing there. Annual totals hit records in 2024, and Q2 2025 continued up. When custody moves by app with identity bound to the person and the metal—and when documents live in one chain—the common scams have fewer seams to pry open. That’s not theory; it’s the direct answer to how theft is happening now. CargoNet+1

‍

You don’t need more paper; you need proof at the moments that matter. Verify, then dispatch. Bind entity, money, human, and metal—twice. Keep one clean document thread from rate con to POD. If you want this workflow live in your brokerage—including app-based dispatch and a single, auditable trail—let’s turn it on and measure it against your week.

Sources for context: CargoNet 2024 annual + Q2 2025 theft updates; FMCSA fraud/identity theft advisories; product briefs from Highway, Truckstop RMIS/SaferWatch, Carrier411, and DAT. 

‍